On Friday, former Los Angeles County Sheriff Jim McDonnell was sworn in as the new chief of the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD), assuming the role with a base salary of $450,000. Approved by the Los Angeles City Council, this salary places McDonnell among the highest-paid police chiefs in the U.S. for a major city. The council had initially proposed $507,509 but settled on $450,000 after deliberation, though it still marks a significant increase from the $391,268 base salary of his predecessor, Chief Michel Moore, who retired earlier this year.

McDonnell’s compensation has drawn scrutiny, particularly as Los Angeles faces ongoing budget challenges. “Why wouldn’t we start him at a lower rate, given the city’s financial situation?” questioned Police Commissioner Maria Lou Calanche. Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum, noted that West Coast police chiefs generally command higher salaries, though McDonnell’s pay is notable even within that trend.

Community Backlash Over Immigration Stance

McDonnell’s appointment faced vocal opposition from immigration advocates, who recalled his tenure as LA County Sheriff, where he reportedly worked with federal immigration authorities, leading to deportations within immigrant communities. Protestors at his confirmation hearing expressed concerns about potential risks to undocumented residents under McDonnell’s leadership.

In response, McDonnell pledged that the LAPD would not participate in mass deportations, stating, “Los Angeles is a city of immigrants, and my job is to protect this city.” He assured that officers would not inquire about individuals’ immigration status or arrest them solely based on it, emphasizing his commitment to the safety of all residents.

A New Chapter for LAPD Leadership

With a 10-2 city council vote, McDonnell’s appointment signals a new chapter for LAPD as he takes charge of nearly 9,000 officers. McDonnell, who served almost 30 years with the LAPD before leading the Long Beach Police and later the LA County Sheriff’s Department, brings extensive experience to the position. During his tenure, he implemented successful crime reduction strategies and fostered improved community relations, earning him recognition as a seasoned law enforcement leader.

McDonnell’s vision for the LAPD includes a firm commitment to transparency, accountability, and the protection of vulnerable communities. Mayor Karen Bass, who selected McDonnell from a group of top candidates, highlighted his deep roots in law enforcement and his ability to navigate complex challenges, setting the stage for a new era of leadership in Los Angeles.