Marine Veteran Acquitted in High-Profile Subway Chokehold Death Case
A Manhattan jury on Monday acquitted Marine veteran Daniel Penny of criminally negligent homicide in the subway death of Jordan Neely, a case that became a national flashpoint for debates around public safety, race, and vigilantism. The trial highlighted stark societal divides, drawing protests and political commentary from across the spectrum.
The jury’s decision came after deliberations that saw the more severe charge of manslaughter dismissed due to a deadlock. Penny, 26, faced potential prison time for both charges. The jury’s verdict clears him of criminal wrongdoing in the death of Neely, who died after being held in a chokehold for six minutes in May 2023.
The Subway Encounter
Neely, a 30-year-old former street performer who struggled with mental illness and homelessness, boarded a subway train in Manhattan, reportedly shouting that he was hungry and didn’t care if he died or went to jail. Witnesses said he hurled his jacket to the floor and made alarming gestures but did not physically harm or approach anyone. However, some passengers reported fearing for their safety.
Penny, a Marine veteran traveling from a college class, restrained Neely from behind in what his attorneys described as a civilian restraint, claiming he was acting to protect fellow passengers. Video footage captured Penny maintaining the hold for several minutes, during which Neely eventually became unresponsive. Despite bystanders’ warnings, Penny released him only after Neely had gone limp.
The city medical examiner ruled Neely’s death a homicide caused by compression of the neck. However, Penny’s defense disputed the finding, citing other contributing factors, including Neely’s mental health conditions, the presence of the synthetic drug K2 in his system, and a pre-existing blood disorder.
A Divisive Case
The case struck a nerve nationally, with prominent Republicans hailing Penny as a hero who acted to protect others, while Democrats and activists called attention to the systemic failures surrounding mental health and homelessness. Demonstrations frequently occurred outside the courthouse, underscoring the charged atmosphere.
Prosecutors argued that Penny’s actions were excessive and unjustified, particularly as the threat diminished when the train doors opened. They accused him of overreacting to a perceived threat without viewing Neely as a human being in crisis.
Penny’s defense maintained that his actions were a reasonable response to a chaotic and unpredictable situation, rooted in his military training to de-escalate threats. A Marine combat instructor, however, testified that Penny misapplied the chokehold technique he had been taught.
A Life of Struggle
Neely’s life story, marked by trauma and resilience, emerged during the trial. Once a beloved Michael Jackson impersonator who entertained subway passengers, Neely spiraled into mental illness after his mother’s murder when he was 14. Diagnosed with schizophrenia, he cycled through hospitalizations, homelessness, and struggles with substance abuse.
Witnesses testified about his erratic behavior on the train that day, but also noted that he was unarmed and carrying only a muffin. Some passengers described him as frightening, while others expressed sympathy for his visible desperation.
Legal Fallout and Broader Implications
Penny chose not to testify, relying on character witnesses who portrayed him as calm, compassionate, and selfless. His defense framed his actions as a split-second decision in a high-stress situation, arguing he held no intent to harm Neely.
The trial’s conclusion does not mark the end of legal proceedings for Penny. Neely’s father has filed a wrongful death lawsuit, seeking civil damages for his son’s death.
The case has sparked renewed discussions on how society addresses mental health, homelessness, and public safety in urban environments. Advocates are calling for systemic reforms to prevent future tragedies.
👉 Stay informed with real-time updates and in-depth analysis at NewsLink7.com. Fact-checked news that matters. Follow us 24/7, 365 days. There are no sides, just the truth. Explore more stories and stay ahead with NewsLink7.com.