In a strongly-worded piece published ahead of the Republican convention, the New York Times editorial board has declared, “Donald Trump is unfit to lead,” as he is set to be officially named the party’s presidential nominee for the third time in eight years. The editorial criticized the Republican Party for aligning with Trump, describing him as “demonstrably unsuited for the office of president,” and highlighting that his values, temperament, and ideas starkly contrast with the principles that have historically made the United States strong.
Biden’s Potential Step-Down
The editorial also addressed President Joe Biden, suggesting that for Democrats to retain the White House, Biden might need to step aside. The board cited his perceived decline, particularly after a poor debate performance against Trump in Atlanta last month.
Concerns About Trump’s Cognitive Fitness
Focusing on the dangers posed by Trump, the editorial questioned his cognitive fitness. According to the Times, many voters feel “frustrated, even despondent.” A recent survey from the Washington Post, ABC News, and Ipsos indicated that 67% of US adults (including 58% of Democrats) want Biden to step down, while 50% of US adults (but only 11% of Republicans) feel the same about Trump.
Praise for Past Republican Leaders
The editorial praised former Republican leaders like Ronald Reagan, George HW Bush, John McCain, and Mitt Romney for their efforts to solve national problems. However, it criticized current Republicans for overlooking their concerns about Trump due to his stances on immigration, trade, and taxes. The board argued that the stakes of this election are foundational, emphasizing the qualities that matter most in a president and commander-in-chief.
Trump’s Legal Issues and Ethical Concerns
Trump’s numerous legal issues were detailed, including 34 criminal charges related to hush-money payments during the 2016 election, 54 other criminal charges involving election subversion and classified documents, and significant fines in civil cases for business fraud and defamation. The editorial highlighted Trump’s attempts to overturn the 2020 election, which led to the January 6 attack on the US Capitol, resulting in nine deaths, approximately 1,300 arrests, and hundreds of convictions. Despite being impeached for inciting the insurrection, Republican senators acquitted Trump, allowing him to run for office again.
Leadership and Character Flaws
The Times editorial board concluded that Trump’s actions demonstrate a character unworthy of the presidency. It stated, “He has demonstrated an utter lack of respect for the constitution, the rule of law, and the American people. Instead of a cogent vision for the country’s future, Mr. Trump is driven by a desire for political power: to use government levers to advance his interests, satisfy his impulses, and seek retribution against those he believes have wronged him.” The editorial firmly declared Trump “quite simply, unfit to lead.”
Democratic Concerns and National Security
While acknowledging legitimate concerns among Democrats about Biden’s age-related fitness, the editorial emphasized that the importance of the debate lies in the potential danger Trump poses to the country’s strength, security, and national character. It urged American voters to seriously consider Trump’s past actions and promises, and understand the significant implications of his potential return to power.
A Call to Civic Duty
The Times concluded by expressing disappointment in the Republican Party for abandoning its longstanding values and ignoring Trump’s systematic dishonesty, corruption, cruelty, and incompetence. It called on American voters to perform a simple act of civic duty in an election year: listen to what Trump is saying, pay attention to what he did as president, and consider the consequences of his promised actions if he returns to office.